“Robbed and hijacked.”
This was the cry of United national Congress members yesterday, as they claimed they were denied the opportunity to make contributions to debate on the Valuation of Land Act and Property Tax Amendment Act 2018 after the bill was wound up contrary to what was agreed to on Friday.
Speaking at a press conference at the Opposition’s Port-of-Spain office, Chief Whip David Lee said not only was the UNC shut down but so too were some 350,000 people who make up various Opposition constituencies.
“What was displayed in Parliament on Friday was a blatant dishonesty and oppression by this Government and on the people of T&T. The Parliament is the people’s place where the people’s views are heard,” Lee said.
He said they now believe Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley and Finance Minister Colm Imbert, who led off debate, did not want to bring any sort of clarity and information on what was described as a “draconian piece of legislation.”
Lee said at the beginning of the sitting there was an agreement between himself and Leader of Government Business Camille Robinson-Regis regarding how the debate would proceed.
“She came to me and told me that she would only be fielding three speakers and I would have to field three speakers and she would like to end the sitting on Friday at around 6.30 pm...not the debate. I asked her was the debate ended and she said, ‘No we would come back at another time to speak and another day to debate the bills.’ So clearly, on Friday the debate was not supposed to have ended because she gave me the assurance the debate would continue for another sitting and maybe more than one other sitting,” Lee said.
He said a “traditional decorum” practised in the House was that the Government would lead off a bill, following which an Opposition member would respond. But he said when Opposition MP Barry Padarath ended his contribution around 5.10 pm on Friday, they expected Attorney General Faris Al-Rawi to respond, but this did not occur.
“We were shocked that he did not get up to speak and that the Finance minister stood up to wind-up the debate. Clearly we were hijacked,” Lee said.
He said Padarath was at the time raising issues from the Hansard in 2009, in which Rowley, a backbencher then under the Patrick Manning administration, was “dead against” Property Tax.
“Clearly, Rowley did not want to explain to the population why all of a sudden he had this change of heart,” Lee added.
Lee said they will now have to review the Standing Orders to see if they have any recourse, adding they will also have to work with the Speaker of the House to ensure there was fairness and equity.
Tabaquite MP Dr Suruj Rambachan, who was also present and echoed similar sentiments, said Parliament is supposed to be a place where there was trust and decorum.
“One expects that the agreements that are made will in fact be respected. When that trust is betrayed it speaks volumes as to how that Government would behave in terms of public matters and matters of public affairs. This matter of the Property Tax is a matter that is of concern to the entire population,” Rambachan said.
Referring to an example given by Imbert that some home owners would have to pay $81 per month in property tax, Rambachan said for many families that was a lot.
“Eighty-one dollars per month means nothing to a minister making $50,000 a month, but it means a lot to person working for a minimum wage of $15 per hour...the salary of a minister is 24 times that person. This shows the callousness and the lack of compassion the Government has for people,” Rambachan said.
The UNC said it intends to hold mass public meetings throughout the country to inform its members and the public that the views of the people could no longer be heard in Parliament.
AG: UNC caught napping
The Opposition was caught napping.
This was the response from Attorney General Faris Al-Rawi when contacted about the Opposition’s claims yesterday.
Noting it was Opposition MP Bhoe Tewarie’s turn to speak but he was not in the House at the time, the AG said on three occasions House Speaker asked if there was “any other Opposition member to speak.”
“Not a single member stood up. The Speaker also asked if the Finance Minister should wrap up and not a single member stood up and that was when the Finance Minister proceeded,” Al-Rawi said.
He said the Opposition showed blatant lack of preparation and indiscipline, adding that its members were “caught napping.”
Saying the Government had done nothing wrong and didn’t need to apologise regarding the Opposition’s allegations, the AG added, “Opposition member Bhoe Tewarie was not even in his seat. The Opposition was also struggling with relevance and on several occasions the Speaker had to remind the members about this.”
He added that yesterday’s press Opposition press conference was “nothing more than an excuse to explain its lack of preparation.”
Robinson-Regis meanwhile told CNC3 last night that while an agreement was reached that three speakers from each side would debate, there was no agreement that this would be one speaker from each side at a time. But Tewarie said he was scheduled to speak, but argued the AG was due to speak before him.